karl_lembke (karl_lembke) wrote,


Just spotted this item at the top of this post in Terry Karney's LJ:

I’m exhausted. The process of my radicalisation proceeds. Tonight, in the mess hall, one of my fellows was going on about the Iran situation. That led to a comment of a cynical nature, about the Gulf of Tonkin, and then my support (when I was told not to pull a Rosie O’Donnell) was to point out the problem of the “unaccounted for yellowcake from Niger” that Rice trotted out as part of our justification for the war.

Things went a tad south after that. I pointed out that his claims that no one had positively disproved that Hussein might have gotten uranium from Niger was asking to prove a negative, and the argument that, “there might be some from somewhere” could always be trotted out.

My response:
I just popped over to FactCheck.org to see what they had to say about yellowcake.
The famous “16 words” in President Bush’s Jan. 28, 2003 State of the Union address turn out to have a basis in fact after all, according to two recently released investigations in the US and Britain.

Bush said then, “The British Government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa .” Some of his critics called that a lie, but the new evidence shows Bush had reason to say what he did.

  1. A British intelligence review released July 14 calls Bush’s 16 words “well founded.”

  2. A separate report by the US Senate Intelligence Committee said July 7 that the US also had similar information from “a number of intelligence reports,” a fact that was classified at the time Bush spoke.

  3. Ironically, former Ambassador Joseph Wilson, who later called Bush’s 16 words a “lie”, supplied information that the Central Intelligence Agency took as confirmation that Iraq may indeed have been seeking uranium from Niger .

  4. Both the US and British investigations make clear that some forged Italian documents, exposed as fakes soon after Bush spoke, were not the basis for the British intelligence Bush cited, or the CIA's conclusion that Iraq was trying to get uranium.

A number of people are trying to cast the statement that Hussein was trying to secure uranium from Niger as a lie. The fact is, they so desperately want the statement to be a lie, they're willing to ignore and lie about facts as needed.
Tags: tk watch

  • "I Am Woman -- Protesting a Strong Woman"

    (Copied from my other blog) This came over the transom last night. After I degaussed my irony meter, I decided to share this with my loyal readers…

  • Hmmm.

    A post is up at the Usual Suspect defending Barack Obama's choice of pastor. My post: Interesting... A blogger styling himself "Instaputz"…

  • Scooter Libby

    Remember that question I posted a while back? Bob commits crime X, which has a statute of limitations of five years. Twenty years later — fifteen…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.